| 1922 James A. Mitchell | 1956 Paul Berger | 1988 Anthony J. Roman |
| 1923 James A. Mitchell | 1957 Lawrence Conway | 1989 Anthony J. Roman |
| 1924 Hulbert Young Jr | 1958 Arthur Kohne | 1990 Micheal J. Huneke |
| 1925 Robert D. Cardwell | 1959 Ron Engle | 1991 John D. Urbach, II |
| 1926 James Marrison | 1960 Edward Engle | 1992 David F. Bobart |
| 1927 Thomas Beck | 1961 Steven Giniatis | 1993 David F. Bobart |
| 1928 Leonard K. Brown | 1962 John Schilling | 1994 Brian M. McGinn |
| 1929 Leonard K. Brown | 1963 Barton Osbourne | 1995 Timothy M. Nason |
| 1930 William N. Rosser | 1964 Robert Newberry | 1996 Daniel J. Reynolds |
| 1931 Charles C. Kraus, Jr | 1965 Kenneth Hankins | 1997 Daniel J. Reynolds |
| 1932 F. LeRoy Hutchins | 1966 Roger Volrath | 1998 Jason Bivens |
| 1933 Philip T. Thomas | 1967 Anthony Coleianne, Jr | 1999 Steve Hall |
| 1934 Philip T. Thomas | 1968 J. Micheal Cribbs, Jr. | 2000 David Buckler |
| 1935 (Reorganization | 1969 William Doyle | 2001 James Fleek |
| 1936 Period - No Chief) | 1970 Stu Lipton | * Greg Singer |
| 1937 Edwin H. Perkins, Jr | 1971 Lynn Sipe, Jr | 2002 Chris Smith |
| 1938 Edwin H. Perkins, Jr | * Mike Chapman | 2003 Ian MacLean-Blevins |
| 1939 Edwin H. Perkins, Jr | 1972 Harry L. Shaw | 2004 John Crowe, IV |
| 1940 Edwin H. Perkins, Jr | 1973 Ken Buddenbohn | 2005 Matt Davis |
| 1941 Edwin H. Perkins, Jr | * Roger Bone | 2006 Glenn Tolley |
| 1942 J. Frank Supplee | 1974 Barry Williams | 2007 Henry “Buddy” Young |
| 1943 William F. Pramschufer | 1975 Steve Maternick | 2008 AJ Eckstein |
| 1944 Allen Muhlback | 1976 Mike Bay | 2009 Christopher P. Smith |
| 1945 John F. Shettle | * Tim O’Neil | 2010 Michael Staskowiak |
| * Dodd S. Carr | 1977 Tim O’Neil | 2011 Ryan Kivinski |
| 1946 Dodd S. Carr | 1978 Kelly Peck | 2012 Michael Phillips |
| 1947 Dodd S. Carr | 1979 Barry Imler | 2013 Colin Ganley |
| 1948 Earl H. Palmer | 1980 Mike Forrest | 2014 Ian Ferris |
| 1949 David Wallis | 1981 Robin Johnson | 2015 Timothy C. Martin |
| 1950 Edwin H. Perkins, Jr | 1982 Wayne Haythorn | 2016 Thomas Carr |
| 1951 Paul Raycob | 1983 Douglas O’Connell | * Tony Sheaffer |
| 1952 John Carroll | 1984 Vince Conway | 2017 Tony Sheaffer 2018 Ethan Kincaid |
| 1953 Reginald Gruber | 1985 David F. Healey | |
| 1954 Edward Huneke, Jr | 1986 David F. Healey | |
| 1955 Ronald Bowie | 1987 Stephen A. Johnston | * Elevated to fill term |
